Our research reveals what to consider when choosing a cost-effective car, the top 20 economical and practical cars from Toyota, Honda, Suzuki, Kia, Subaru, VW (and more), understanding the total cost of ownership and frequently asked questions.
Updated 8 April 2024
Summary:
Cars, petrol, insurance, repairs and finance keep increasing in price, and we don't see that reversing anytime soon.
This means owning a car is an expensive exercise; the key to controlling ever-increasing costs lies in making informed choices. Buying a shiny new car can be tempting, and almost everyone in the industry will load you with debt to do it, but for many, it's an unaffordable luxury that can limit your life choices, freedom and happiness.
The reality is that cars are among the biggest depreciating assets we buy - get it wrong and you're effectively burning money every day you own the car.
The trick is to find a sweet spot - a car that's affordable to buy, economical to run, and cheap to repair will reward you without draining your bank account.
Know This: How much you pay for a car is just the start of your commitment. The real cost of car ownership unfolds over time, and New Zealanders continue to be squeezed on fuel costs, repairs, insurance and the inevitable depreciation.
Financially aware drivers buy cars that ticks all the boxes - affordable purchase price, low fuel consumption, reasonable insurance renewals and minimal maintenance costs.
Whatever your needs, whether you need commuting, weekend adventures, or a reliable runabout, there's a car for you. Our list of New Zealand's top twenty cost-effective cars to buy and drive covers a range of different models and sizes.
Our guide covers:
Important: The insights provided in our guide are journalistic in nature and based on extensive research from authorities such as the NZTA, RightCar, AA New Zealand research, Trade Me Motors research, MoneyHub insurance research, historical Stuff.co.nz research and Consumer.
We are not endorsing or recommending any car, and we advise readers to consider their specific needs and circumstances.
Smart upfront decisions can lead to substantial savings that give you more choices during a cost of living crisis. Before buying a car, it's essential to understand what drives the costs you'll be stuck with paying so you can make a wise, cost-effective choice:
Important: The cheapest car to buy isn't always the cheapest to own - there are a lot of variables hence the need for full consideration before going any further.
Our guide below is based on detailed research from a range of authorities. Together, these cars cater to a diverse range of needs and preferences.
From eco-friendly pioneers to family-friendly SUVs and rugged adventurers, there's a car for every lifestyle, each with its own balance of depreciation, efficiency, maintenance, insurance, reliability, parts availability, and resale value.
While we present these cars without a specific ranking, each has been selected for its standout qualities in providing economical and practical motoring solutions for New Zealanders.
Our list is categorised to cover the needs of the majority of New Zealanders looking for cheap cars to buy and run. These include:
Owning a car is more than just the price tag - it's an ongoing financial commitment. Don't overpay upfront and have your life held back because of running a car - it's all too common, completely miserable and always avoidable.
We explain key factors to let you understand the key factors you need to consider.
Examples of when car ownership is affordable and when it gets expensive.
1. Compact Cars Example - Liam's Toyota Yaris vs Jade's Mini Cooper
2. Family Cars Example - Ethan's Mazda CX-5 vs Olivia's Range Rover Evoque
3. Electric Vehicles Example - Chloe's Nissan Leaf vs Noah's Used Tesla Model S
4. SUVs Example - Sarah's Mazda CX-5 vs Tyler's BMW X5
Our View: These case studies highlight that the "better" choice isn't always the most luxurious or the one with higher performance. Cars like Toyota Yaris, Mazda CX-5, and Nissan Leaf (among others) represent sensible decisions that balance upfront costs, running expenses, reliability, and resale value.
In contrast, while offering certain advantages, cars like the Mini Cooper, Range Rover Evoque, Tesla Model S, and BMW X5 have higher total costs of ownership, making them financially challenging in the long term, and even more so if you've financed the purchase.
Resale value is influenced by brand reputation, vehicle condition, mileage, service history, and market demand. Popular colours and models often hold value better. Timing can also play a role; for instance, 4WD vehicles may fetch higher prices in winter.
EVs can be more cost-effective due to lower running costs, such as electricity vs. petrol and reduced maintenance needs. However, higher purchase prices, battery replacement costs, and the road user charges introduced in 2024 should be considered.
Increasing your excess, comparing policy prices, determining whether a multi-policy discount is worthwhile, maintaining a clean driving record, and installing safety features can lower premiums.
Lab tests provide a baseline, but real-world fuel efficiency can vary due to factors like driving style, terrain, and vehicle load. To estimate real savings, consider your typical driving conditions and compare them with real-world data from existing users.
Yes - hybrids can be economical due to better fuel efficiency and reduced emissions. However, the cost-benefit depends on your driving habits, fuel prices, and the price differential between hybrid and non-hybrid models.
Safety features, fuel efficiency, maintenance costs, and resale value are key. Space and comfort are also important. Choosing well-equipped base models rather than higher-end versions is often more economical.
Maintenance costs can vary based on manufacturer, model, and parts availability. Japanese brands like Toyota and Honda are known for reliability and lower maintenance costs, whereas European brands can be more expensive.